I’ve been here a long time. I feel increasingly out of touch with the HN crowd. A lot of talk about pricing, profitability, and capability, and little discussion about how the potentially devastating negative consequences of technology like this. Not that I have the solution, but my main reaction to these latest developments is: “I don’t want any of this.” This applies not just to this announcement, but the rest of the ones on the home page, too.
Obviously you're entitled with this opinion, but others are entitled with their opinions too. For example, they might want to:
> talk about pricing, profitability, and capability
"I don't want any of this" doesn't really add much to the discussion. I can copy & paste "I don't want any of this" to any HN submission, be it a Nintendo switch emulator, the 1001th javascript framework or yet another Lean-verified math proof of an open math problem.
Thank you for posting this, I share the sentiment and I have been feeling the same way for a while. I had not put words onto it. I understand the urge to talk technical details. I also don't enjoy the lack of critical distance that is required to have educated discussions. Right now, it feels like we are talking about margins while brushing past the broader human cost.
You don't want it, millions don't want it or like it, and yet, it continues. It's a dead-end conversation. I'm not thrilled about it, but it's reality. The cat is not going back in the bag.
yup, but 2 billion people use it. As you said, the cat is not going back in the bag. I can't think of any disruptive technology that has ever, effectively, been put back in the bag.
Yes, what are the negative consequences of being able to fake anything? I can only think of several bookshelves of speculative sci fi, and a number of movies, exploring this.
This isn't the same place it was 10 years ago it's been Ship of Theseus'd from a place for hackers to a place for nontechnical managers, spammers, growth marketers, etc. This is appropriate content for them.
What negative consequences? Everyone out of a job? Human thoughts and feelings aren’t “sacred”? Who cares. Bring on the future. Get excited for it. I want robots to do everything. Can’t wait for physical LLMs to do to the physical world what LLMs did to the online one.
Who cares, I’ll take the future when it comes. If everyone is out of a job we’ll figure out a way, or we won’t. Either way, I am pumped for this.
Can you imagine a future where you can have a group of 50 robots and you can say clear this land and build a hospital here and they just do it. We can see that in our lifetime if we don’t mess it up.
And that’s somehow different from today - are you necessary now? Someone decided to keep you around for now, to do something for them, that you won’t be needed to do tomorrow? I don’t think that’s how it works or will work.
When I was first starting out all the real programmers were up in arms about Visual Basic allowing idiots to code without understanding what was going on.
This is just another layer of abstraction, as hard as people try to cast it as something more. A powerful lever, but still humans pulling that lever.
The Unabomber's primary point was that every time leverage increases, it takes power and freedom from folks at the bottom. But I think he underestimated how much unhappiness came with plagues and dysentery...
> he underestimated how much unhappiness came with plagues and dysentery...
we just got out of a pandemic which didn't kill as much as the black death but probably caused depression / mental health issues in a large part of the population.
I feel like too many people have near 0 historical perspective. I'm sitting in my house, with hot water and artificial light. I can have my lunch cooked for me and delivered to me with ingredients from around the world and eat it while being entertained by a world class entertainer on a screen in front of me.
Things that maybe only the top 0.01% could do 150 years ago.
It is still an option to go live in the woods somewhere and live where cutting your hand on a rock might be a death sentence.
Then everyone in the industry should demonstrate what new plagues they're solving with the new leverage, probably. Cancer would be a good one to start with.
> When I was first starting out all the real programmers were up in arms about Visual Basic allowing idiots to code without understanding what was going on.
Lol. What a dumb analogy. Understandable, given the choice of defending not understanding what's going on.
Welcome to HN, where everyone is running 69 agents 24/7 babysitting each other, when they wake up they look up 34 startups these agents created (all with fancy landing pages and full SaaS microservice infrastructures deployed on serverless) and they decide the next steps from their bed, talking to Claude on their phone.
While most of the world uses AI not even knowing it is AI, because they type stuff into Google search and it spits out the answer, just like it always did (right?).
2. Other people want things. The measuring stick of whether a product is useful isn't just whether you'd use it. When I don't want something I mostly just don't click.
I appreciate this is a HackerNews Bingo item at this point but... I do really wish Google were clearer on if or how I can pay them money to use their stuff.
It says this is available to "Eligible Google AI Ultra subscribers" but it looks like my workspace account isn't allowed one of those, so I'm looking with my non workspace gmail account and that says Ultra gets Genie 3. I don't know if that's because I'm in the UK (a previous Genie version was US only) or if its because they haven't updated their marketing spiel and I have no way to know if that would make me an "eligible" subscriber or not.
DeepMind do such awesome work and its a shame that there's this layer of bigcorp frustration for users to get at it.
Google has no idea about its accounts. I have an American account with AdSense accounts tied to a Canadian address from before 2010 that I can't verify but I'm verified but now I'm stuck because AdMob requires me to have an AdSense account but I can't close the Canadian AdMob account because it I can't close the AdSense account and there is no one to help. It's a complete mess.
My business pays Google thousands of dollars per month, including at least hundreds for AI. I shouldn't have to know the answer to that question to get access to the latest and greatest models. I might pay by the token to try it out for a day, and that should be easy for me to do but it's not even worth trying.
It's really neat, and some people are convinced this could someday be how game engines work. I do wonder if Google would ever let people remake games like GTA on something like this if it ever were capable of being a game engine. Technically, this could be Roblox on crack if they ever went that far with it.
Yet none of these demos are available to the public while this is from GPT 6.2 because it only needs to be produced by the neural net once: https://cathedral-walk.openai.chatgpt.site/
I can't even see what 'genie' is on their website and I'm not gonna sign up for a 20x plan just to take a look. A demo may get me to signup, but I'm not gonna signup sight unseen.
Deepmind is creating so much that, at least to me, feels done for the love of the craft instead of earning potential, that I cannot but appreciate their work. Like, how could this end up being profitable?
That’s.. actually insane. Just imagining a Claude operating a robot arm with a tool call that leveraged something like this to “imagine” scenarios before acting.
Build realistic worlds -> Unleash robots in them to have more realistic, synthetic training environments. You know, just like the current world us humans live in. Turtles all the way down and all.
Architects have actually lived in that world for a long time thanks to CAD software enforcing defaults which are even more restrictive. The Autodesk CEO once said something like, "when I walk through building I can tell which version of AutoCAD was used to make it."
Humans are memetic, and culture is reactive. Hence why aesthetic trends shift wildly over short periods of time.
The more AI learns about design, the more humans learn about how AI designs, and will react to it seeking out the opposite. Ambition and expectations will grow just as fast as capabilities do. Jevons.
Creativity will be fine. It's your apparent negative emotional disposition I'm more worried about.
I mean do they expect people using Genie to be on acid or mushrooms so you don't notice that everything changes when you turn around?
I get that will probably be somewhat fixed at some point, but I doubt Genie will be some kind of platform for games that have real rules. And in any case, every minute of playing it's basically microwaving a dinosaur somewhere.
They make too much money with ads to care about running a proper business for anything else. If that source were to run dry they'd have to get their act together on all the other projects.
Obviously you're entitled with this opinion, but others are entitled with their opinions too. For example, they might want to:
> talk about pricing, profitability, and capability
"I don't want any of this" doesn't really add much to the discussion. I can copy & paste "I don't want any of this" to any HN submission, be it a Nintendo switch emulator, the 1001th javascript framework or yet another Lean-verified math proof of an open math problem.
That helped with a lot of tech trends before AI existed and continues to work quite well.
yup, but 2 billion people use it. As you said, the cat is not going back in the bag. I can't think of any disruptive technology that has ever, effectively, been put back in the bag.
Could you say a few words on this?
Sure, then your existence is not necessary anymore.
Can you imagine a future where you can have a group of 50 robots and you can say clear this land and build a hospital here and they just do it. We can see that in our lifetime if we don’t mess it up.
I'm an optimist that we'll figure our way out, but I don't think it makes sense to be "pumped" for the "we won't" if that happens.
OH NO!
Not on my venture capital backed discussion board for tech startups!
Is it really a surprise?
^ I could have added a bunch of other nothing burger like you but the essence was just this. So.
This is just another layer of abstraction, as hard as people try to cast it as something more. A powerful lever, but still humans pulling that lever.
The Unabomber's primary point was that every time leverage increases, it takes power and freedom from folks at the bottom. But I think he underestimated how much unhappiness came with plagues and dysentery...
we just got out of a pandemic which didn't kill as much as the black death but probably caused depression / mental health issues in a large part of the population.
we die less, suffer more because of tech
I feel like too many people have near 0 historical perspective. I'm sitting in my house, with hot water and artificial light. I can have my lunch cooked for me and delivered to me with ingredients from around the world and eat it while being entertained by a world class entertainer on a screen in front of me.
Things that maybe only the top 0.01% could do 150 years ago.
It is still an option to go live in the woods somewhere and live where cutting your hand on a rock might be a death sentence.
otoh, no private enterprise can afford to find the cure for cancer
Lol. What a dumb analogy. Understandable, given the choice of defending not understanding what's going on.
While most of the world uses AI not even knowing it is AI, because they type stuff into Google search and it spits out the answer, just like it always did (right?).
HN bubble is real. And it's fun :)
2. Other people want things. The measuring stick of whether a product is useful isn't just whether you'd use it. When I don't want something I mostly just don't click.
It says this is available to "Eligible Google AI Ultra subscribers" but it looks like my workspace account isn't allowed one of those, so I'm looking with my non workspace gmail account and that says Ultra gets Genie 3. I don't know if that's because I'm in the UK (a previous Genie version was US only) or if its because they haven't updated their marketing spiel and I have no way to know if that would make me an "eligible" subscriber or not.
DeepMind do such awesome work and its a shame that there's this layer of bigcorp frustration for users to get at it.
are you 20x?
Being able to spin 360° degrees and not have details around you change...
Then, you could do some really wild things like say that a full turn is 180° or add some magic system or any number of creative tweaks.
My god we are so cooked.
The feeling of AI recently is Lovecraftian indeed.
The more AI learns about design, the more humans learn about how AI designs, and will react to it seeking out the opposite. Ambition and expectations will grow just as fast as capabilities do. Jevons.
Creativity will be fine. It's your apparent negative emotional disposition I'm more worried about.
> Discover new Genie 3 capabilities
So there's a "Genie 3" still floating around? Who decides these things at Google??
Do people not day dream? I can imagine much better than this.
"But you cant share your dream" is not a valid defense. I definitely can talk stupid shit with my friends and laugh about it.
I get that will probably be somewhat fixed at some point, but I doubt Genie will be some kind of platform for games that have real rules. And in any case, every minute of playing it's basically microwaving a dinosaur somewhere.
Like, nobody cares, Google. Why would anybody even pay attention to you when you cancel projects just as often as you start them.
Genuinely the most ADHD company in existence.
TV / movies are an insane waste of resources, just read a book, who needs moving pictures? Same for videogames.